Barbour: The Ultimate Review of Waxed Cotton Coats and Bedale’s Waterproof Challenge

This marks my first exploration into the world of Barbour jackets. To say I’m enthusiastic would be an understatement.

Key Takeaways

Initial Impressions

There’s a wealth of information we need to explore, especially when comparing sylkoil and thornproof wax finishes. Each has its own charm and uniqueness. Understanding these differences can elevate your choice of jacket.

I recently conducted a waterproofness test, which I’ll gladly share. We’ll discuss fit, my reasoning for selecting the Bedale, its classic nature, and why the hood is an essential accessory – there’s much to cover, and I’m eager to dive in.

Fit and Sizing

Having chosen the classic Bedale, it’s important to note the British heritage associated with Barbour jackets. Although I’m still discovering that cultural aspect, there’s also an ivy/preppy style that I’m exploring.

Barbour includes a distinctive pin with every jacket. While some choose to display it, others do not. The choice can be contentious, but I’m all for showing off my Barbour badge proudly.

I selected the Bedale over the slimmer Ashby version because I want a jacket that will last a lifetime. Choosing the classic cut felt wise, anticipating potential changes in my body shape over the years. The fit is comfortably oversized.

It’s not particularly sleek, but when I tried the jacket on in-store over both a flannel and sweater, the Bedale felt roomier—almost as if I wasn’t wearing anything extra at all.

For reference, I stand 5’9″ and weigh around 150 pounds, opting for a size 36 instead of my usual 38. The 36 provided a generous fit, so I recommend sizing down if you can’t try it on beforehand.

Sylkoil vs. Thornproof

Let’s venture outdoors to examine how well these materials perform in nature. If you’ve researched Barbour, you’ll know the distinctions between the thornproof and sylkoil finishes. Each has unique qualities that provoke lively debate.

The differences largely come down to cotton processing methods. While I find some nuances elusive, the core distinctions between the two finishes are becoming clear.

Sylkoil represents the original Barbour finish made from uncombed cotton. This uncombed state allows for a fluffier, more textured appearance compared to the thornproof finish.

Thornproof cotton, on the other hand, is combed and processed to achieve a sharp, smooth finish that is less prone to snagging. This difference becomes essential when contemplating outdoor usage.

The visual difference between the two is marked: sylkoil has a glossier, slightly oily look, while thornproof offers a matte, glass-like finish. Both are distinctive in style, yet one might lean toward the protective qualities of the thornproof option.

To illustrate, think of a loosely knit fisherman’s sweater versus a sheet of glass. If you walk through thorns, the snagging likelihood of the sweater increases, whereas the glass pane offers an unyielding barrier. This encapsulates the core difference between sylkoil and thornproof jackets.

This analogy highlights the crucial differences in durability and weather resistance between the two finishes. The processing methods significantly impact their functionality and longevity.

Thornproof involves a meticulous combing process, resulting in a tightly knitted fabric. The cotton goes through high-pressure rollers that seal the weave, enhancing water resistance. The finish appears shiny, as the tightly woven threads create a barrier even against thorns.

While my excursions through thorns yielded positive results with the jacket appearing intact, thornproof provides robust wind and water resistance due to its tight weave. The fabric’s durability can’t be overstated, especially when considering outdoor activities.

Exquisite Details

This jacket has quickly claimed a spot as one of my favorites, thanks to its impressive features and modular design. Allow me to break down some details that set this jacket apart. One standout feature is the zipper that doubles as a bottle opener—perfect for those spontaneous moments.

The corduroy collar, equipped with snaps for an optional hood, is another thoughtful design choice. A hood enhances versatility, especially on unpredictable days when you might not want a hat.

Moreover, the interior features a tartan lining, offering a textured, hefty feel that assures longevity. Barbour also boasts a comprehensive repair program, enabling you to customize your jacket with patches, adding to its character over time.

The jacket is partially lined. However, there are zippers that allow you to add a quilted lining for colder months. Personally, I prefer layering with sweaters; therefore, I might skip this feature. Overall, the craftsmanship in every element, including the knit storm cuffs and storm flaps, is impressive—keeping water at bay when fully zipped.

Furthermore, additional snaps enable a throat latch, securing the collar during inclement weather. Each detail is not merely functional but thoughtfully executed, making this jacket an incredible investment.

Moreover, the moleskin-lined hand warmer pockets are exquisite for keeping your hands warm. This jacket combines practicality with style seamlessly.

The thoughtful touches distinguish this jacket, from the stitching to the fabric quality. It is not just aesthetically pleasing, but built to withstand the test of time—it’s a wardrobe staple I can’t praise enough.

Water Resistance and Longevity

The Patina Effect

It’s essential to discuss the beloved patina effect associated with Barbour jackets. As you wear the jacket, a unique character emerges with an array of greens accentuating the fabric.

The catch is that this aesthetic appeal indicates a reduction in wax or oil, potentially compromising water resistance in those areas. Thus, while you enjoy the evolving beauty, you may need to balance form with function.

Water Resistance Test

I took this jacket into the shower to properly assess its water resistance. Contrary to some claims that these jackets fall short in waterproofness, the truth is nuanced. This largely depends on the maintenance of your jacket over time.

A well-maintained jacket with a fresh coat of wax is considerably water resistant. If the wax begins to fade, as evidenced by lighter shades of green, you may experience water infiltration. Fortunately, my jacket passed the shower test admirably without any leaks—testament to its superior treatment.

Historical anecdotes suggest many outdoorsmen have found themselves soaked when their jackets eventually succumbed to storms. While these garments are not fully waterproof, their water resistance can exceed expectations if correctly cared for.

This jacket feels like a reliable companion, one I’d enthusiastically recommend for outdoor adventures. Its blend of functionality and style is spot on and ready for any excursion.

Final Reflections

This jacket inspires wanderlust and can surely accompany you on many journeys, evolving alongside you. If you’re contemplating a Barbour jacket, investing in one is worthwhile—it’s a beautiful representation of both style and substance, just like you.

I look forward to sharing more insights with you soon!